Search This Blog

Wednesday, October 28, 2026

Tom Thomson's Sunset and Shore, September 1916 TT-Post 118

DRAFT - Work in progress...

"Untitled (Sunset and Shore)"
Oil on wood
8.43 x 10.51 (21.4 x 26.7) cm
Tom's paint box size, 1916
Diana and Bob McElroy were the inspiration behind this post, based on Tom Thomson's "Sunset and Shore" painted around September 14th, 1916, at about 6:30 pm EST. Tom was standing very near N45.867196° W77.757537°, looking roughly toward 275 degrees (westerly) from the sandy and rocky point 150 feet west of the Out-Side-In. An autumn weather system was crossing Achray on the northwest shore of Grand Lake. A thunderstorm passed just to the north of the Out-Side-In the previous hour. Most of the weather would pass north of Achray while the cold frontal passage and subsequent clearing were only an hour away.

Boots on the ground are essential to understanding the true story. The explanation of how we can discover all of the above details more than 110 years after the event will follow.  The meteorology of this painting is beautiful, but that science has been explained before in several other posts. The interesting weather clearly written cloud-script is always intriguing. The fact that Thomson recorded the meteorological clues in his wild brushstrokes and colours is frankly phenomenal. Art can bring meaning to life, but of course, that is only my opinion.

The important background story can only be discovered in the details. The most important fact is the painting location, and that was accurately provided by Diana and Bob. Those specifics can only be found by going to the place where Thomson painted and witnessing those clues in person. That takes time and dedication, not to mention passion for the adventure. 

Diana and Bob are in the same league of art explorers as my friends Jim and Sue Waddington. I touched on their story in "The McElroys to the rescue - Tom Thomson's Petawawa Gorges; Night 1916" along with several other posts. The combined efforts of these teams are required to really appreciate the magic that was Tom Thomson and the Group of Seven. 

The painting location for "Sunset and Shore" was determined to within a few feet. The photographic evidence accumulated by Diana and Bob is irrefutable. They even investigated the Algonquin Parks archive to historically substantiate their findings and to place the results within the context that was also Thomson's. 

My friends at the Algonquin Park Archives and Collections (APPAC x2024.4.1) have shared their photographs of the V.B. Gray 1925 canoe and fishing expedition in Algonquin Park between May 21 and June 1, 1925. That shore of Grand Lake has changed much since then. The following image shows the canoes on the sandy beach with considerable forest debris higher above the water's edge. Those stumps would have been floated to their location at times of higher water levels. The lake levels were controlled by a dam at the outlet of Grand Lake to facilitate the movement of logs downstream. The spring "flood" might have already been released to flush the 1924 harvest down to market. 

The following post will rely mainly on graphics and pictures to tell the story. That will save a lot of words and maybe even make the tale more interesting. 

The graphic below links the landmarks in Thomson's painting to features in the 1925 Algonquin Archival photograph. 

Another archival image reveals the distant hills in the right portion of Thomson's painting. Tom carefully matched the characteristic shape of each hill! You might need assistance to see the referenced hills! That is a fine catch of trout. I have never had a stringer of fish to match that. 

The following graphic clarifies those distant hills and a few more details in both the archival photo and Tom's painting. 

A century of forest recovery can mask the landscape that Thomson painted in 1916. The trees can easily disguise the features that Tom witnessed. The 2026 trees had thickened enough to block out any "sky holes" within the forest canopy. 


The front-lit rock is not obvious in the McElroy autumn picture, while the dark backlit rock in Tom's September painting is glaringly obvious, contrasting with the bright sunlight glinting across the lake. That rock is not obvious in the 1925 archival images due to front lighting. The higher water levels typical of late spring might also have at least partially submerged that rock in 1925. 

That portion of the Grand Lake has changed much since 2025. The following graphic overlays Tom's "Sunset and Shore" and the V.B. Gray 1925 image with the August 2nd, 2025 Airbus image from Google Earth. The permanent part of the modern dock (i.e. the 'peninsula' of fill and gravel) may have affected the current in the lake.  It flows from roughly northwest to southeast. 

As Diana mused, "I think it probably still carries some sand along the lake.  The dock would create a gentle eddy, which might have caused additional deposit of sand in the 'bay' created.  The prevailing wind could have added to the effect as well."

The conclusion with the estimate of the position of the 1925 shore and how that has changed in the last century reveals Tom's "Sunset and Shore" painting location as being only 150 feet from the location of the historic "Out-Side-In. The top-down view provides a better lay-of-the-land perspective. 


Diana and Bob McElroy's meticulous investigations on several trips to Achray revealed the exact painting location for Tom Thomson's "Sunset and Shore". The location alone would have been sufficient to establish the 1916 date for this work. The year was also included on the edge of the panel where the painting slid in and out of Tom's paint box. Tom only painted around Achray in 1916 when he was employed as a fire ranger. His art was insufficient to make a living, so he had to accept other employment. Vincent Van Gogh, the Dutch "Thomson", also experienced similar experiences. 

Now this is where meteorology and science can be confidently applied with exact knowledge of place and direction of view. 

Altocumulus castellanus cloud is characteristic of mid-level air mass instability. The favoured location for these clouds and the swells is with the cyclonic companion of the warm conveyor belt of a weather system. These details are included in a top-down view of a typical mid-latitude weather system. The jet stream provides the energy to fuel and steer the storm. The jet stream also carves the "dry slot" into the back edge of the associated "comma cloud pattern". 


The lack of wind-gravity waves within the swells further substantiates the above conclusion. The following graphic depicts the portion of the weather system that Tom would have been viewing from his earthbound perspective - the green shaded trapezoid in the right portion of the graphic.  


The final bit of detective work is based purely on the sun! Only the bottoms of the clouds above Diana's “lone skinny dead tree at the right end of the point" are illuminated by the sun. Three very deliberate strokes of brighter, yellow oils were applied only to the bottoms of those altocumulus clouds stretching along the deformation zone. Thomson's powers of observation were remarkable, and his intentional inclusion of these details in his painting allows us to complete the Creative Scene Investigation. 

The sun had to be below the horizon. If one scales Tom's painting to the appropriate size to match the features in the Google Earth image provided by the Airbus, one can calculate that Tom's viewing angle to the sun was 275 degrees. From Tom's 1916 painting location of N45.867196 W77.757537, the sun is visible at that angle only on March 27, 1916 (Spring occurrence) or September 14, 1916 (Autumn occurrence). We know that Tom did not report for his fire ranging job until early May of 1916. The colours of the foliage in Tom's painting are also more characteristic of autumn. The conclusion is that Tom was painting at sunset around September 14th, 1916. Sunset on that date and at that location was at 6:22 pm EST. 


If we make allowances for "Artistic Licence" and permit the sun to actually be 2 degrees to the left or to the right of Diana's srawny dead tree, the limits of the plein air painting can be set as:

Earliest September 13, 1916 with a sunset time: 6:28 PM EST to
Latest September 20, 1916 with a sunset time: 6:14 PM EST. 

I also asked my colleague Johnny Lade to have a look at this painting as if he were making a weather observation. Known to his students as "Johnny Met", he has a lifetime of experience observing the actual weather. Johnny nailed this observation since Thomson painted exactly what he saw. John was unaware of the time, location and any direction of view but observed: 

"Tom displayed a beautiful sunset in this painting. It is almost twilight time with the sun low on the horizon, allowing the colours of orange and red. Tstm (thunderstorm) west moving east. Ltgcg (lightning cloud to ground)."

These thoughts are consistent with all of the preceding remarks. Johnny's aviation phrasing brings back some fine memories. 

Thus, the CSI conclusion has been reached:
  • Tom Thomson's "Sunset and Shore" was painted around September 14th, 1916 at about 6:30 pm EST. 
  • Tom was looking toward 275 degrees (westerly) from the sandy/rocky point 150 feet west of the Out-Side-In on the Grand Lake shore of Achray, very near N45.867196° W77.757537°. 
  • An autumn weather system was crossing Grand Lake, and a thunderstorm probably passed just to the north of the Out-Side-In. 
  • The cold front and dry slot would soon reach Achray, followed by clearing and cooler temperatures.
"Untitled (Sunset and Shore)"
Oil on wood
8.43 x 10.51 (21.4 x 26.7) cm
Tom's paint box size, 1916

Tom was possibly alerted to the weather and the painting opportunity by the thunderstorm passing just to the north of Achray. Viewing the colours in the sunset sky would have been enough impetus for him to grab his plein air kit and head out to the point to paint. Tom's painting included again above is full of colour and excitement!

I remain amazed and gratified by the considerable amount of dedicated effort and investigation into the art of Tom Thomson. Many individuals like Diana and Bob McElroy, with broad ranges of expertise and experience, contribute unique insights into the art of Thomson. It would be a pity not to share this information with the larger art community. The art of Tom Thomson still helps to define the social fabric of Canada. We are all in this together, attempting to learn each day. 

Harris and MacDonald, pictured below, did their very best to catalogue the art of their friend. Unfortunately, due to World War One, they were unable to accompany him for many of the works they were attempting to document from Thomson's Shack in the spring of 1918. Those bold panels were all very "cold cases," at least a couple of years old to Harris and MacDonald. They were assigning titles, dates, locations, and other information as best they could. MacDonald had never been to Algonquin, which made the effort especially challenging. Viewing Thomson's final sketches would have been emotional for his friends, who were certainly still grieving his loss. 


The details of any Inscriptions and the Provenance for Thomson's "Sunset and Shore" are limited compared to Thomson's other paintings. Dr. MacCallum, Thomson's main patron, acquired this work, but the exact details are unknown. 

        • Artist: Tom Thomson 
        • Title: Untitled (Sunset and Shore)
        • Date: 1916
        • Materials: oil on wood
        • Dimensions: 21.4 x 26.7 cm
        • Credit line: Bequest of Dr. J.M. MacCallum, Toronto, 1944
        • Accession number: 4707
"Untitled (Sunset and Shore)"
Dr. MacCallum did play an important role in preserving, placing, and promoting Thomson's art found in The Shack after Tom passed in July 1917. MacCallum sold 29 oil sketches to the National Gallery of Canada in 1918! Upon his passing in 1943, MacCallum bequeathed 85 additional works by Thomson to the National Gallery of Canada, with "Untitled (Sunset and Shore)" being included in that group. 

A 2018–19 National Gallery of Canada (NGC) report stated that approximately 53% of its collection had been digitized, while close to 30% of the works were available online for public viewing. "Untitled (Sunset and Shore)" only recently became available for viewing more than a century after Tom created it. 

That NGC report also described plans to improve digitization but acknowledged that "limited resources had slowed progress". I wonder what other Thomson weather depictions might become available when that digitization effort is completed. 

I would have enjoyed being able to view the entire surface of this Tom Thomson painting without the large acquisition sticker! There are good reasons for most decisions, but there must be a better way other than a big, bold, obscuring label.  

The label on the front also makes one wonder what is on the back! Tom was employed as a fire ranger that summer, so he was not prepared to be an artist. Tom sometimes used both sides of his available painting surfaces that year. A notable example is a classic paint box wooden panel with "View from the Top of a Hill" on one side (left below) and "Yellow Sunset" on the other (right below). The investigations to untangle those brilliant works were challenging but revealed much about Thomson. 


As with other Thomson paintings, the name "Untitled (Sunset and Shore)" does not come close to describing the subject or the motivation for Tom's efforts. Thankfully, Harris and MacDonald did manage to correctly identify this as a sunset work! About a third of Thomson's colourful skies with "sunset" in their names are actually sunrises, as revealed in "Tom Thomson Was A Weatherman - Summary As of Now".

One goal of these posts is to provide details about what might have been Tom's real motivation for picking up his brushes. Art historians have important expertise in attribution, provenance, materials, and the history of art. Those skills do not automatically give them the best knowledge of every aspect of a painting. Scientifically interpreting the details included in the brushstrokes and knowing the landscape in which it was painted are different kinds of expertise. The strongest scholarship draws on all potential sources of information. All of the information needs to be assembled to really understand and appreciate the art. 

Independent researchers can bring knowledge that institutions lack. Formal qualifications provide valuable training, but they don't confer exclusive ownership of insight or discovery. Thoreau MacDonald (1901-1989), the son of JEH MacDonald of the Group of Seven, and also a friend of Tom, may have summed it up best when he wrote:

“Thomson’s work would be a fine study for some competent critic, but anyone attempting it should be familiar, not only with every phase of his work but with the country too, lakes, rivers, weather; have them in his bones … “

Passionate art sleuths like the McElroys and Waddingtons provide the boots on the ground and the paddles in the canoes required to sleuth the required information. Weather was a big motivation for Thomson, requiring meteorology and the associated sciences to fully comprehend his art. I can help with that...

"Sunset and Shore" as it would have
 appeared in Thomson's Paint Box

The stringer of large trout highlighted in the Algonquin Archival images symbolizes the bounty of nature still readily available in Thomson’s days. Nature held the promise of apparently unlimited wealth to be harvested for free in the waterways and forests. The stump with twisted roots on the Achray beach was a tombstone testament to the forests that had been clear-cut. Tom included it in his plein air painting simply because it was there. Clearly, such wholesale harvesting of nature was and is not sustainable. 

Tom Thomson was possibly an early environmentalist, seeing the beauty of the "bare and broken branch" and documenting the frenzied plundering of those precious natural resources.

The powerful and wealthy industrialists of that day did not comprehend where their deeds would lead just a century later.  Ironically, Francis Molina’s article Remarkable Weather of 1911: The Effect of the Combustion of Coal on the Climate — What Scientists Predict for the Future was published just a month before the Titanic sank on April 15, 1912. The Titanic was recklessly travelling at its maximum service speed of 22 knots despite receiving multiple warnings of icebergs in the area. Remarkable arrogance... or just ignorance? The Titanic might have enjoyed a long and useful career of service if only the captain had heeded the iceberg warnings that had been posted. I cover that story in #3034 "Fiddler's Elbow Wildfire Sunset".

Thomson’s art was only understood and appreciated by a very select few in his day. Ronald Pittaway's interview with Tom Thomson's Mowat Lodge friend, Daphne Crombie, on January 14th, 1977, included the following statement: 

“At that time, they were terribly criticized and it was said that these paintings were alright to hang in the kitchen.”


How the world has changed since then! How might that self-destructive course have been corrected if people only appreciated the nature of Tom's art and the environment?

I remain indebted to the McElroys for their guidance in navigating the story behind "Sunset and Shore".

Thank you for taking the time to read this!

Warmest regards, and keep your paddle in the water,

Phil Chadwick, Tom Thomson Post TT-118

PS: Tom Thomson Was A Weatherman - Summary As of Now contains all of the entries to date.